Its a stalemate between edward and jacobI know that edward is hot and all but it was kinda stupid to leave bella even if he thought it was for her own good. I can't say anything wrong about jacob because he saw an opportunity and he took it. There's nothing wrong in that. As for looks lets admit bot of them are really hott but you can't just pick one because everybody has different tastes and different likes and dislikes. i personally love edward more than jacob but thats just me!!